Winners & Losers

Investigating the human and ecological impacts of the commercialisation of

non-timber forest products (NTFPs)


Home Project Overview Case Studies Project Partners Documents Links


 

Project Overview

 

Introduction

Commercialisation of non-timber forest products (NTFPs) has an impact on poor farmers and landless people, as well as on traders and small-scale entrepreneurs who use the products. In aiming to achieve sustainable development, this project looks at the economic and ecological effects of commercialisation on the forest resource base and people’s livelihoods. Studying the distribution and marketing of Marula and Crabwood products can reveal generic relationships between commercialisation and community, showing that there are many pathways for commercialising NTFPs, and their impacts can be very different both on stakeholders and on the resource itself. By examining different market chains, we will be able to identify suitable development paths, so that commercial returns are not achieved at the expense of ecological sustainability and other social, cultural and environmental benefits.

 

Project objectives

The purpose of this project is to examine the economic and social impacts of commercialisation of non-timber forest products on resource poor farmers and landless people, and on artisans, traders and small-scale entrepreneurs who make use of such products. In addition, with a view to contributing to the achievement of sustainable development, we will examine the ecological impacts of this commercialisation process on the forest resource base. The distributional impacts of commercialisation will be examined within the marketing chains for Marula and Crabwood products in South Africa, Namibia and Guyana. This will reveal the generic relationships between commercialisation and community impacts, assessed in terms of changes in natural, human, social, financial and physical capital entitlements. This analysis will demonstrate that there are numerous pathways for commercialisation of non-timber forest products, and that (depending on the specific circumstances) commercial activity can have very different impacts both on the stakeholders and on the resource itself. At one extreme, large-scale profit-maximising organisations can have little impact on the rural poor, and sometimes can even have a negative impact on natural capital. At the other extreme, community-based initiatives can benefit many poor people, ensuring at the same time that forest resources are not depleted unsustainably. The project team hopes to identify sustainable development paths that achieve the desired social, cultural and environmental benefits.

 

Poverty alleviation

There is increasing interest throughout the world in natural products. Many such products from tropical and sub-tropical areas may be suitable for sale in the large markets of the developed world. The use of NTFPs can make a significant contribution to household incomes, and thus their commercialisation may have significant potential. It must be realised, however, that commercialisation of these valued and often ecologically vulnerable types of NTFPs can only be effective with an adequate understanding of:

 

  particular socio-economic or political circumstances where commercialisation is planned

 

-  the constraints on commercially generated monetary income actually reaching poorer households

 

-  whether NTFP commercial harvesting will be ecologically sustainable

 

This project explores the many pathways associated with the commercialisation process, and seeks to identify the “winners" and "losers” arising from commercialising different NTFPs from two tree species in Southern Africa and Guyana. At sites selected for their commercial activity and/or their traditional livelihood practices, a comparative study will be made of the impacts of commercialisation on the natural, human, social, financial and physical capital of poor communities.

 

 

Research methodology

This project uses a variety of approaches to address the relevant issues. Resource inventory surveys and analyses are being conducted, and household surveys of livelihood strategies/product use are being carried out in the appropriate locations. Assessment of the commercial market chain is being made through data collection and analysis in both Southern Africa and Guyana, and a Geographical Information System (GIS) database is being built. In addition to this, email and telephone surveys are taking place in the OECD and other developed economies, to estimate market potential for products from Crabwood and Marula trees. Issues of intellectual property rights (IPR) and benefit sharing are also being investigated, and legal expertise is being brought to bear to enable best practice guidelines for NTFP commercialisation to be produced.

 

 


CEH Wallingford pages  

This website is an output from a research project funded by the United Kingdom Department for International Development (DFID) for the benefit of developing countries.
The views expressed are not necessarily those of DFID. Project R7795 Forestry Research Programme.
For more information about this project contact Dr Caroline Sullivan Design by Dermot O'Regan
Last updated on 15 December 2005 © CEH Wallingford 2003